Get a Free Ebook

Five Inspirational Truths for Authors

Try our Video Classes

Downloadable in-depth learning, with pdf slides

Find out more about My Book Therapy

We want to help you up your writing game. If you are stuck, or just want a boost, please check us out!

Sunday, July 26, 2009

Saving the Church from the Cornfield

by Mike Duran

"We want to take the hick out of the word ‘evangelical.’" That according to Marvin Olasky, provost of The King's College in New York City. Olasky's response was part of an exposé by the New York Times. Their article, In a Worldly City's Tallest Tower, A College with a Heavenly Bent, asks the question:

What is an evangelical Christian college doing in the middle of New York?
That question, like it or not, is as much a reflection of contemporary Christian culture as it is the secular mindset towards it. The inference on the part of the NY Times writer is that Christianity is out of place in a cosmopolitan urban center like New York City. Thankfully, King's leadership sees otherwise:
“We see ourselves as a value-adding school, where we are bilingual; we can speak ‘Christianese’ and also express our ideas in ways that change people’s views,” said Andrew Mills, the chairman of the college’s trustees. “We wanted a school that engages in debates, and it’s hard to have those debates from the middle of a cornfield in Iowa.”
Of course there's nothing wrong with the church in "the middle of a cornfield in Iowa." America is as much defined and shaped by rural, small city demographics (the Cornfield), as it is by its urban centers (the City). The problem is when the Church abandons the City for the Cornfield.

King's setting, college leaders say, was a deliberate move. They wanted students to be exposed to new ideas and hone their intellectual chops far from the “holy huddle,” places that are religiously and ideologically sealed off from the rest of the world.
The college’s mandate, Mr. Mills said, is to encourage students to engage people with differing viewpoints, and ideally to shape public discourse “in a way that is winsome, and not screechy from the Christian right.”
This concept of "engaging people with differing viewpoints" has always been troublesome for the Church. Cultural engagement, for many evangelicals, has become nothing more than societal critique, followed by condemnation, followed by retreat. Preaching to the choir is much safer than enduring the slings and arrows of the marketplace of ideas. Besides, the cornfield has fewer ears than the big City. Is it any wonder why a Christian college seems so anomalous to downtown New York? We've abdicated our role to the barbarians.

In some ways,
the misconception that the church belongs in the Cornfield rather than the City is the result of Christians, not secularists. Early fundamentalism was characterized by cultural withdrawal. For many, holiness came to be associated with abstinence from "wordly" pursuits and institutions. Refraining from drinking and dancing, movies and makeup, became articles of faith for Fundies. By the mid-20th century, Christians of orthodox persuasion were scarce at institutions where, in many cases, they were once prominent: newspapers, publishers, eastern universities, etc. There was a great exodus out of Hollywood, while Christian musicians brooded over Jerry Lee's hellraising and Elvis' hip-shaking. The metropolis came to be viewed as a Babylon or Gomorrah -- something to be fled from, rather than engaged. Fundamentalism, in part, forced Christianity into a cultural, intellectual, Cornfield.

We are children of our spiritual ancestors' flight, and the current Christian subculture is the byproduct of that retreat. Christian art -- film, fiction, literature -- emerged as an "alternative" to worldly art, something we could consume without feeling unholy.
Rather than return to the marketplace, we created an "alternate sphere" of culture; we left the City in favor of the Cornfield. Instead of sprinkling our influence throughout the culture, we distanced ourselves from it, created a parallel universe free from secular influence or critique. We surrendered the University to the heathen, established our own centers of learning, our own studios, publishing houses, and sound stages, far from Broadway and Nashville (spiritually speaking).

It's no wonder that the secular world sees Christianity as acclimating better to the Cornfield than the City -- we've given them little reason to believe otherwise. In this sense, the NY Times question --
What is an evangelical Christian college doing in the middle of New York? -- is indeed appropriate. The question facing Christian authors is this: Does contemporary Christian lit help us engage culture or withdraw from it; does it move us toward the City or remove us into the Cornfield of irrelevance?


  1. Thanks for a thoughtful review of a creative Christian enterprise.

  2. There are christians in New York, and it's not unusual for christians to have things in New York. It's just perhaps unusual to think of 'evangelical christians' to have a presence in New York, although they certainly do exist. New York is often associated with a left-wing, liberal atmosphere which is not what evangelical christians are commonly associated with.

    Christ needs to be proclaimed in the cities and in the country. We must not engage in the sins of this world, but that doesn't mean that we stay out of this world. We must endure the temptations of this world to give Christ's message to those in it.

    contemporary christian lit has a task for evangelization to bring Christ's message to readers who have not heard it, and this can be difficult at times, although with the grace of God it is achievable.

    God Bless,

  3. Interesting question. I wonder if it's the non-cornfield Christian books that get the "reader beware" stickers in the Christian bookstores.

  4. City and cornfield, and the problem coming when the church abandons the city for the cornfield -- well said.

  5. Thanks, Marvin! I appreciate your work.

  6. In one thing King's College has not departed from traditional evangelical practice: the faculty is overwhelmingly male. Still, I applaud the mindset, absolutely.

    I'm still trying to figure out what it means in practical terms for me as a writer, to try to break out of the Christian bubble. In attempting this, I think I've succeeded in writing something that everybody will be uncomfortable with... LOL


Don't be shy. Share what's on your mind.