Saturday, February 01, 2014

7 Ways to Avoid Overwriting

posted by Michelle Griep for Janalyn Voigt
A sign bearing this quote by an unknown author hangs in my office, a powerful reminder that I write not to massage my mind but to be understood.  I’ve had to learn this the hard way.

When Eric Wilson, a NY Times bestselling author, agreed to read the first chapter of an epic fantasy work-in-progress, I labored to make it stunning with awesome descriptions and catchy phrasing. Eric came back with the gentle remark that I am a good writer who doesn’t need to grandstand. Let the story shine through, he told me. After I got over my initial reaction to this comment, I reread my manuscript. Wouldn’t you know it, but he was right. I’d been showing off my skill with words rather than serving the story. I reworked DawnSinger, and it found a publisher.  

I went over the manuscript a ‘last time’ before sending it to my publisher, hoping to avoid edits. One of my strengths as a writer, I am told, is the ability to bring settings to life for readers. Playing to this strength, I added even more description, having completely missed Eric’s advice that I needed to work on pacing. Back came my manuscript for the first round of edits with many of the descriptive passages I’d worked so hard to create either crossed out or marked for shortening. Through more rounds of edits than I’d care to admit to, I learned to carve away not only extraneous description, but everything that didn’t support the story.

When I edit I always confront that dreaded monster, Purple Prose. Over time I’ve cut that beasty down to size. Edits for Wayfarer, book two in my Tales of Faeraven trilogy, were lighter, and I believe they’ll be easier yet for DawnKing, book three. Eradicating my tendency to overwrite has developed my deep instinct for story, and anything that detracts annoys me as much as fingernails on a chalkboard.

The cure for overwriting is to focus on story.

I summed up my thoughts on the difference between storytelling and storycrafting for my agency’s blog, Wordserve Water Cooler in ‘Are You A Storyteller or Storycrafter? In this post I make the point that story always trumps craft. That’s not to say vivid descriptions and skillful phrasing aren’t important, but in the right places. Knowing where these are takes practice, humility, and the feedback of others. I can offer a few tips gleaned from my own experience, though.

How To Avoid Overwriting

1. Include your character in scene descriptions. I made the mistake of taking too literally the advice to treat your setting as a separate character. In every scene, describe the location as part of the point-of-view character’s experience. This will automatically cut out some tangents you might otherwise embark on.

2. Avoid excessive use of adverbs and adjectives. One sign of strong writing is that nouns and verbs pull their own weight and don’t need to be propped up with other words. Take the presence of an ‘ly’ word as a challenge to find a better verb or noun .

3. Avoid overuse of phrases using participles (words ending in ‘ing’). Strong sentences don’t need to lean on tacked-on phrases. However, it’s important to vary sentence structures, so eliminating participial phrases altogether isn’t necessary or desirable. Balance is the key here.

4. Be appropriate for your genre. Writers of fantasy or historical fiction often need to add a bit more description to convey foreign or bygone worlds. This doesn’t grant the writer a license to bog down readers in detail, though. One of the most important skills a writer can develop is the ability to convey a lot with an economy of words.

5. If you notice a string of little words in a sentence, chances are you can cut some of them or recast the sentence to avoid wordiness.

6. Let dialogue do its work. Pare beats or dialogue tags to those needed for clarity. Opinions vary on what is too little or too much, though. Watch for agreement in the feedback you receive. Where there is no agreement, trust your instinct as a storyteller.

7. Question every scene to make sure it needs to exist. Sometimes combining two scenes into one makes sense. If cutting a scene doesn’t impact the story, or if you can sum up an entire scene with a sentence elsewhere, your course is clear. Making cuts can help your pacing and decrease the likelihood readers will skip over passages. Readers who have not been slowed by extraneous passages will have more patience for your book overall.

Honing a strong sense of story can’t be taught, only refined. It can take time but is worth the effort. In a crowded marketplace a gifted storyteller stands apart.

BONUS!!!

Love settling down with a warm cuppa and a good book? Enter to win a $20 Starbucks card in the Wayfarer Launch Celebration Giveaway Drawing. Entries close at midnight on February 8th. The winner will be announced on February 15th at http://JanalynVoigt.com.

Wayfarer Launch Celebration $20 Starbucks Card Giveaway.
One person will win a $20 Starbucks card. One entry per person per day.

Janalyn Voigt's unique blend of adventure, romance, suspense, and fantasy creates worlds of beauty and danger for readers. Tales of Faeraven, her epic fantasy series beginning with DawnSinger, carries the reader into a land only imagined in dreams.

Janalyn is represented by Sarah Joy Freese of Wordserve Literary. Her memberships include ACFW and NCWA. 

When she's not writing, Janalyn loves to discover worlds of adventure in the great outdoors.

Author Site for Janalyn Voigt: (author journals, travel journals, guest journals, and book news)

Site for Writers: Live Write Breathe (teaching articles plus free How to Edit PDF)

10 comments:

Michelle Griep said...

Just gotta say it again...LOVE your book covers!

Jennifer said...

I tend to underwrite. I actually need to add when I finish...

Janalyn Voigt, escape into creative worlds of fiction. said...

Thanks for featuring me! The link to sign up for the Starbucks card giveaway is: http://www.rafflecopter.com/rafl/share-code/NGRkYjg2NWYwNzYwMWZhMWI3OTIyYzJjYTliZGY5OjM=/

Phyllis Wheeler said...

Good advice, succinctly put!

Tracy Krauss said...

This is such wonderful advice, Janalyn! Your list of things to avoid at the end of the post was very practical, too.

Janalyn Voigt, escape into creative worlds of fiction. said...

I'm glad you found my advice helpful.

christine edwards said...

Two weeks ago, I attended a writer's conference and sat with a phenomenal literary agent. She read my first chapter and then met back up with me the next day to discuss it. This never happens so I was stoked, of course.

She said my story had all the right things, great characterization, sturdy plot, and most importantly, it was interesting. Why else would she meet with me a second time, on an unforgiving park bench outside a beachside resort, for 45 minutes no less?

She said she would've rejected my query though, because I had overwritten. She gave me back my chapter with great notes, and went one by one through her comments to show me what she meant. I took notes as we spoke as well, and felt I understood her critique, but since then have struggled with implementing the changes. I can't count how many conversations my writing partner and I have had where we poured over her notes trying to nail down the right way to make the necessary changes without sacrificing my voice.

This article touched on all her points and has helped me immensely. I know I'm on the right track now, and that my recent edits are in line with her constructive criticism. Thank you so much!

Ron Estrada said...

Great advice Janalyn. I've struggled with over writing. It's amazing how much better a story is when you cut the clutter.

Janalyn Voigt, escape into creative worlds of fiction. said...

I'm glad to have been of help to you, Christine. You can do this.

Janalyn Voigt, escape into creative worlds of fiction. said...

Thanks, Ron. Cutting clutter is something I'm doing around the house as well. Hmm...maybe there's a correlation.