by James L. Rubart
When I turned in my latest manuscript to my publisher on April 1st, I had little idea if it was any good.
But when I got feedback from the first two of my three trusted beta readers, I was encouraged.
The first said, "One of your best." The second said, "Brilliant."
The third said, "Uh, so sorry, Jim .. but I just didn't get this one. At all."
So when I got the letter from my editor saying she didn't get it either, I wasn't entirely surprised. But it was still a blow.
Where Do We Go From Here
Whether you're an indie author, or traditionally published, the above can--and probably will---happen to you. So here's a few quick tips on how to handle things:
- Vent- "What's wrong with them? How could they miss it?" or "What's wrong with me? I'm a hack, why did I ever think I could write?" Vent your emotions. It's okay. But I highly recommend venting to your agent, or spouse or friends instead of your editor or beta readers.
- Reengage- ask your editor and/or beta readers what went wrong. I'm in the enviable position of truly liking my editor not just as an editor, but as a great friend. I know she wants the absolute best for me, and I know it was tough for her to send that letter saying my story was only firing on two of six cylinders. So when we put together a schedule for brainstorming on how to fix the manuscript, it gave me hope.
- Accept the fact it's highly likely they know what they're talking about- that's why we have editors and beta readers. They're looking at the forest while our faces are smashed into the bark of the trees. If the story isn't clicking for the people you trust, then believe they have insight you don't have this time around.
- Don't give into the temptation to publish the book anyway- I debated for a few days about writing an entirely different book for my publisher and indie-publishing the one they rejected, but realized that would be foolish. It would cheat my readers, my publishers, and ultimately me.